Construction delay · Hillsborough County · Thirteenth Judicial Circuit
Hillsborough County Construction Delay Expert Witnesses
Forensic schedule analysis, expert reports and testimony on construction delay for public works, transportation, utility and private projects in Hillsborough County, led by Daniel R. Zorrilla, J.D., BSBC, CGC, CFCC.
The short answer
What a construction delay expert does on a Hillsborough County matter
Oxley provides construction delay expert witness services to counsel and parties in Hillsborough County construction disputes. Daniel R. Zorrilla, J.D., BSBC, CGC, CFCC, leads the work as testifying expert. He examines the baseline, the schedule updates and the project records to determine whether completion was delayed, which events affected the critical path, and how much time each accounted for. How concurrent delay is treated depends on the contract and applicable law, which are for counsel and the tribunal.
The method is chosen to fit the contract and the records, stated in the report and explained in testimony at deposition, trial or arbitration, and presented at mediation. The analysis addresses the record, including evidence that cuts against the retaining party.
Oxley’s office is at 13830 58th St N, Suite 403, Clearwater, FL 33760, about 17 miles by road from downtown Tampa and the county’s main courthouse. Oxley does not keep a Hillsborough County office. The team travels to Tampa, Brandon, Riverview, Plant City and elsewhere in the county for depositions, mediations, site visits and records work. For downtown Tampa matters, see the Tampa page.
- Testifying expertDaniel R. Zorrilla, J.D., BSBC, CGC, CFCC, President
- Scheduling teamDavid Hengelbrok, P.E., PSP, and Jeremy Easen, BSBC, CGC
- TestimonyDan has testified in more than 40 cases, in state and federal court and in arbitration. He has been retained as a consultant or expert in more than 100 construction matters.
- Phone727-821-9190
Hillsborough County projects
What delay looks like on Hillsborough County projects
Hillsborough County has three incorporated cities, Tampa, Temple Terrace and Plant City, and a large unincorporated area where much of the growth has happened. That growth means roads and interchanges, water and wastewater plants, schools, fire stations and private communities, built under contracts with very different schedule requirements.
Public contracts often share features that drive delay disputes. They set the baseline, the update cycle and what a time extension request must contain. They set notice and claim deadlines that run from the delay event, and many require a time request to be supported by the schedule update. Many assess liquidated damages for late completion, and some for missed milestones. Whether a time request satisfied the contract is a question for counsel and the tribunal. What a schedule analysis can show is what the schedule, the updates and the record support about the time itself.
Private projects in the county, such as multifamily, mixed-use and commercial buildings, are often built under AIA or negotiated contract forms, with liquidated damages and milestones tied to financing or leasing. Private towers, hospitals and mixed-use projects add facade and MEP sequencing, long-lead equipment and phased turnover to the schedule, and a late delivery on one of those items can move several trades at once.
Linear and utility projects behave differently from buildings. A road widening is often scheduled by segment and traffic phase, and a plant expansion by process system and tie-in outage. Delays come from utility relocations, right-of-way, permits, design changes and weather, and the critical path can move between segments or phases. The analysis has to follow those shifts with the contemporaneous updates and not with one summary of the whole job.
Work in or beside roadways, utility corridors and other agencies’ property adds approvals and coordination that sit outside the contractor’s control. Weather, including summer storms and tropical systems, affects outdoor work through much of the year. Separating those causes from planning, staffing and procurement is the core of a delay analysis.
Records
Records that matter most in a Hillsborough County delay claim
Delay opinions rest on dated records. These are the records that usually matter most on this kind of project, and the earlier they are preserved, the more an analysis can support.
- Native schedule files for the baseline and every update, with the narratives that came with them
- Owner, architect and contractor (OAC) meeting minutes and three-week look-aheads
- The schedule specification and the contract’s requirements for time extension requests
- Submittal and procurement logs, with approval and delivery dates
- Notices, time extension requests and change orders, with the owner’s responses and dates
- Utility relocation, right-of-way and permit records on linear work
- Daily reports, photographs and traffic phase records
With those records the analysis can tie each period of delay to a documented event and to the dates in the record. How the contract allocates that time is for counsel and the tribunal.
For a subcontractor, the analysis also uses the general contractor’s updates as issued, the look-aheads and the subcontract’s schedule and notice terms.
Method
How the analysis method is chosen
Oxley chooses the analysis method to fit the contract and the records, including windows analysis, as-planned versus as-built comparison, time impact analysis and as-built reconstruction, as described in AACE International Recommended Practice No. 29R-03. The report names the method and explains why it fits. Method detail is on the construction delay expert witnesses page.
Courts and forums
Where Hillsborough County delay disputes are heard
State court: Thirteenth Judicial Circuit (Hillsborough County only). State cases are heard mainly at the George E. Edgecomb Courthouse, 800 E. Twiggs St., Tampa. The circuit also has a courthouse in Plant City.
Federal court: Middle District of Florida, Tampa Division, 801 N. Florida Ave., Tampa.
Appeals and arbitration: state appeals go to the Second District Court of Appeal and federal appeals to the Eleventh Circuit. Private contracts frequently call for AAA arbitration or another agreed procedure. Dan has testified in arbitration as well as in court.
In every forum the delay opinion has to rest on a stated method and on the project records. The analysis follows the governing contract and the forum’s rules on expert testimony.
Who does the work
Daniel R. Zorrilla, J.D., BSBC, CGC, CFCC
Dan Zorrilla is Oxley’s President and testifying expert on construction schedule delay, disruption, lost productivity, cumulative impact and related damages. He has been in construction since 1991 and in consulting and expert work since 2008. He managed construction for national and regional general contractors before 2008 and returned to project management in 2014–2015. He is a Florida Certified General Contractor, an AACE International Certified Forensic Claims Consultant, a Panelist of the American Arbitration Association, and a member of The Florida Bar. He does not practice law. Work through Oxley is technical consulting, not legal representation. Full profile →
David Hengelbrok, P.E., PSP, and Jeremy Easen, BSBC, CGC, support the scheduling and delay analysis.
Oxley acts for only one party on a project, and fees do not depend on findings. Any earlier role on the project is disclosed at intake.
When this comes up
Situations that call for a delay expert
- Completion delay and related cost consequences are disputed
- An owner needs to test a contractor’s time extension request or support a liquidated damages assessment
- An extension request or a liquidated damages assessment is contested
- An opposing expert’s delay analysis needs a response
- Counsel needs an early view of what the schedules actually support
- Schedule analysis is needed while the project is still running. See schedule review and analysis and delay analysis for contractors
Related work includes delay damages and disruption.
FAQ
Hillsborough County construction delay expert witnesses: common questions
Does Oxley have an office in Hillsborough County?
No. Oxley’s office is at 13830 58th St N, Suite 403, Clearwater, FL 33760, about 17 miles by road from downtown Tampa. The team travels for depositions, mediations, site visits and records work in Tampa and elsewhere in Hillsborough County.
What does a construction delay expert witness do?
A delay expert examines the schedules and records to determine whether completion was delayed, which events affected the critical path and how much time each accounted for. The expert states the method and its limits in a report and in testimony at deposition, trial or arbitration, and presents the analysis at mediation.
Who is the testifying expert?
Daniel R. Zorrilla, J.D., BSBC, CGC, CFCC, is Oxley’s President and testifying expert on schedule delay, disruption and related damages. David Hengelbrok, P.E., PSP, and Jeremy Easen, BSBC, CGC, support the scheduling and delay analysis. His CV and testimony history are available to counsel on request.
Which courts hear Hillsborough County construction delay disputes?
State cases are heard in the Thirteenth Judicial Circuit, mainly at the George E. Edgecomb Courthouse in Tampa. The circuit also has a courthouse in Plant City. Federal cases are heard in the Middle District of Florida, Tampa Division. Many construction contracts send disputes to arbitration instead. Dan has testified in arbitration as well as in court.
When should an owner, contractor or counsel bring in a delay expert?
Often earlier than expected. An owner may need to test a contractor’s time extension request or support a liquidated damages assessment. A contractor may need to document delay when an update shows completion slipping and the parties disagree about why. Counsel may need a view before mediation or when an opposing delay analysis needs a response. On public work the record that decides a time dispute is built month by month, so an early look can show which schedule files are missing.
Does Oxley act for both sides on the same project?
No. Oxley acts for only one party on a project, and fees do not depend on the findings. Any earlier role on the project is disclosed at intake. Oxley provides technical consulting, not legal representation.
Related pages
Nearby areas and further reading
Talk to Oxley
Call 727-821-9190 or send party names and a brief nonconfidential description for conflict review. Please wait until Oxley confirms intake before sending confidential or substantive materials.
